Your promotion path is broken (here's what Gen Z wants instead)


Hi Reader,

A Fortune 500 executive recently confided in me: "We offered our best Gen Z employee a promotion – team lead, more money, clear advancement. She turned it down flat."

His confusion was palpable. "Don't they want to move up?"

Here's the thing: Gen Z absolutely wants to advance. They just don't want YOUR version of advancement.

The Career Ladder Is Dead

Traditional career progression: Entry level → Senior level → Manager → Director → VP

Gen Z career progression: Skills-based growth → Impact-focused roles → Portfolio careers → Entrepreneurial opportunities

See the difference?

What Went Wrong With the Old Model

The Deloitte Global 2024 Gen Z and Millennial Survey revealed something startling: 52% of Gen Z would rather develop expertise than manage people.

But most companies still equate advancement with management responsibilities.

So when you offer a Gen Z employee a "promotion" that involves managing others instead of deepening their expertise, they hear: "We want you to do less of what you're good at."

The Skills-First Revolution

Gen Z doesn't think in terms of titles. They think in terms of capabilities.

Instead of asking "How do I become a manager?" they ask:

  • "How do I become indispensable?"
  • "What skills will be valuable in 10 years?"
  • "How can I create multiple income streams?"
  • "What expertise can I build that no AI can replicate?"

The New Career Framework

Smart companies are abandoning linear career ladders for career lattices:

Vertical Growth: Traditional promotions

Horizontal Growth: Cross-functional skill development

Diagonal Growth: Project-based leadership opportunities

External Growth: Industry recognition and thought leadership

What This Means for Managers

Instead of asking "Do you want to be promoted?" try asking:

  • "What expertise do you want to develop?"
  • "What problems do you want to solve?"
  • "What would make you feel like you're growing?"
  • "How can we help you become known for something?"

The Portfolio Career Reality

Here's a stat that might surprise you: 67% of Gen Z employees plan to have multiple income streams by age 30.

This isn't disloyalty. It's economic strategy.

Gen Z watched Millennials get laid off despite decades of company loyalty. They're building careers that can't be eliminated by one company's downsizing.

Your Action Step

This week, have a "growth conversation" with a Gen Z team member. Focus on capabilities they want to develop, not positions they want to hold.

Ask: "If you could become the go-to person for something in our industry, what would it be?"

The Opportunity

Companies that embrace skills-based advancement will attract the best Gen Z talent. Those that cling to traditional career ladders will wonder why their top performers keep leaving.

Next Week's Focus

I'm diving into the communication channel that Gen Z prefers for work discussions – and why email is actually hurting your productivity.

Keep evolving,

Dr. Colleen

P.S. September marks the beginning of something big. I've been developing a comprehensive system for managers who want to crack the Gen Z code once and for all. Early details coming this month...

Dr. Colleen Batchelder

Check out the resources I offer and sign up for my newsletter!

Read more from Dr. Colleen Batchelder

Hi Reader, FINAL CALL: Early Access Closes Tonight This is it – the final newsletter in our Gen Z management series, and your last chance to join the Gen Z Manager Survival Guide at the early access price. But before I share the details, let me tell you why this matters more than you might realize... The Competitive Advantage Right now, while most managers are still frustrated and confused by Gen Z employees, you have an opportunity to become the manager they actually want to work for. The...

Hi Reader, "Six months ago, I was ready to quit managing. My Gen Z employees were driving me crazy. Today, they're my highest performers and I'm known as the manager everyone wants to work for." This transformation came from Sarah, a director who attended my Gen Z management workshop in April. Her secret? She stopped trying to make Gen Z employees fit her management style and started adapting her style to unlock their potential. The Mindset Shift That Changes Everything Old Thinking: "Gen Z...

Hi Reader, "We invested $50,000 in a leadership development program, but none of our Gen Z high-performers applied." This came from a frustrated VP of People who couldn't understand why their emerging talent wasn't interested in leadership opportunities. When I reviewed their program, the problem was obvious... The Leadership Development That Nobody Wants Their program included: 18-month management track Traditional supervisory skills training Formal mentorship with senior executives Focus on...